The Rhythm Sues Cash Strapped Buyers

The Rhythm at Music Row has become the latest new Middle Tennessee condo development to sue buyers who try to back out of their purchases.

Rhythm Partners LLC, the Brentwood-based developer of the 14-story, 105-unit condo building that came online this spring, filed suit Friday against four buyers who would not or could not close on their units…read the entire Rhythm sues condo buyers story

If you found this article helpful, you may also like:
The Terrazzo is Sued, ILSFDA Cited
Downtown Nashville Condo Update
Bristol Development May Sue..Continued
The Icon In The Gulch – Nashville, TN

Icon Developer Sued by Several Condo Buyers

This article entitled “Some buyers sue to get out of condo deals” appeared in the Tennessean on March the 18th, 2009. The author is Naomi Snyder who can be reached at 615-259-8284:

Now that many condo developers are finishing up work on their buildings downtown, buyers are seeking relief from the courts to get out of buying them.

Several Nashville-area residents filed a lawsuit Thursday in Davidson County Chancery Court against the developers of the 22-story Icon in the Gulch, saying the developers violated the terms of their purchase contracts and federal law.

The plaintiffs, Franke Elliott, David Haley, Scott Williams, Terry Miller and Deborah Williams, are seeking to cancel their contracts and get their earnest money returned, plus punitive damages and attorneys’ fees. Read the full story about the Icon developer sued by several condo buyers.

If you enjoyed this post, you may also enjoy:
The Terrazzo is Sued, ILSFDA Cited
Downtown Nashville Condo Update
Bristol Development May Sue..Continued
Icon in The Gulch – Pictures

Downtown Nashville Condo Update

This article entitled “Condos face crucial test” appeared in the Nashville Business Journal on March the 6th, 2009. The author is Turner Hutchens who can be reached at 615-846-4254:

More than a thousand new luxury condos in downtown Nashville seemed like a good idea at the time.

That was just a couple of years ago, and despite the housing, credit and job busts since, developers argue that it still is…read the entire downtown Nashville condo update article.

If you enjoyed this post, you might also enjoy:
Home Sales for Nashville, TN – December 2008
Mid-Year Nashville Market Update
Developers of The Braxton Are Sued
2 Year Analysis of Nashville Condo Prices

Bristol Development May Sue..Continued

Okay, now that I have had an opportunity to reflect and consider, here are my thoughts at this point:

1) I am not an attorney and my advise/point of view is not a legal opinion
2) I am a Realtor who represents almost 50 purchasers of Bristol Development’s projects, I am also a buyer in these projects
3) I am a fair and reasonable person who considers myself an advocate for my clients and the city of Nashville alike

These are extraordinary economic times. Many of us have never experienced an economy or a banking atmosphere anything like the one we currently experience. It is scary, it is terrifying, and it is uncharted.

That being said, it is my suggestion that we all put the cards on the table and stop playing this high stakes game of poker. It is time for a truce and for cooler heads to prevail.

No one deserves to make a profit on the purchase of their Icon purchase. The buyer, the seller, the developer or the builder. Seriously. We have all taken a risk. The developer has taken a risk with the bank, the buyer has taken a risk with the developer and their own bank, the construction company has also taken a risk with their bank and the developer. Without going into a huge analysis or dissertation on how the American banking industry has crippled, fooled and hurt us all, here is my suggestion.

Buyers who have contracted to purchase a condo in the Icon, including myself, you need to consummate your purchase. Why? Because you signed a piece of paper that promised you would. But, you are not going to pay what your contract says. Instead, the developer, builder and all banks involved are going to sit down in an open forum to share their actual, to date costs with all of us. We are all going to agree that interest is out the window and that actual, hard costs are the key to this equation.

Listen, no one wins here…but, no one loses either. We ALL have taken a risk and we all were wrong. That does not mean that one party or the other needs to be left holding the bag. Buyers, the Bristol Development Group shouldn’t bear all of the costs. Sellers, same thing. These buyers don’t owe you more than what the market will bear. This is simply true and no one will ever be able to squeeze water out of a stone.

Seriously, we have a unique opportunity to pave a bold new road in these ridiculous economic times. It is a road of compromise and a road of equitable fairness. I am bold enough to walk down this path. The question is, are you?

UPDATE 6/5/09:

It was reported in the Nashville Business Journal today that the Bristol Development Group has indeed filed lawsuits against 3 individuals for damages totaling around $80,000. When asked by the NBJ as to Bristol’s motivation for bringing these lawsuits, CEO Charles Carlisle simply replied, “People who sign a contract should expect to perform.” It is interesting to note that the Bristol Group was able to resell all of the condos that fell out of contract, some for higher prices.

I am no fool, it is clear to me that Bristol is sending this loud and clear message: If you don’t plan on closing on your contracted condo, you will get sued no matter if we resell your unit or not.

If you enjoyed this post, you may also enjoy:
Icon Developer Sued by Several Condo Buyers
Bristol Development may sue West End condo buyers
The Icon in the Gulch in Nashville, TN
The Icon In The Gulch – Nashville, TN
2 Year Analysis of Nashville Condo Prices

Bristol Development may sue West End condo buyers

The following article was written by Chas Sisk and was published in The Tennessen on 2/18/2009:
—- —- —-
“The developer of a Midtown condominium is demanding tens of thousands of dollars from people who backed out of their contracts, stepping up the battle over who should pay for the slowing condo market.

Franklin-based Bristol Development Group has told several former contract holders in its Bristol West End project that the firm would pursue legal action if they do not compensate the firm for money it says it lost when the units were sold to new buyers.

The firm has given these former contract holders until the end of the month to pay damages or face a court case. The contract holders, some of whose units were resold more than a year ago, were told they might face litigation in letters sent by special delivery that arrived Monday.

“This is about a handful of people that didn’t fulfill their contracts,” said Charles Carlisle, Bristol’s chief executive. “Bristol honored their contracts.”

Carlisle said the letters were sent to “10 or less” former contract holders, but he declined to discuss details of the demand, citing potential litigation.

The letters, which were sent by the Birmingham, Ala.-based law firm Burr & Forman, are the latest in a series of maneuvers taken by Nashville condo developers to deal with the slow pace of closings in their developments.

Many people who signed up in 2005 and 2006 to buy condos downtown and in Midtown now say they can’t afford to follow through on their contracts because lending standards have toughened and because condo values have fallen.

They say the earnest money deposits they put down on the units, often as little as $5,000, are fair compensation for developers.

But Bristol has maintained that contract holders have a legal obligation to close, even if they forfeit their deposits. As early as 2007, the firm sent letters warning that those who back out of their deals could be dunned for not closing.

Bristol appeared to back off last year as it resold units that had been under contract to new buyers.
But in the letters received this week, the firm says it should be paid the difference between the original and the final sales price, as well as interest, lost profits, marketing, utilities, property taxes, attorney’s fees and homeowners association dues.

The letters also say recipients could be made to pay legal costs if they fight the demand.
Bristol says it will give former contract holders credit for their earnest money, which continues to be held in escrow.

The firm decided to pursue litigation after closing the last of the Bristol West End’s 161 units in October, Carlisle said. He declined to say how much Bristol seeks to recover, but individual letters demand $10,000 to $30,000.

Carlisle also declined to comment on whether Bristol would pursue damages from buyers who back out of its 418-unit tower Icon in the Gulch, which is trying to get contract holders to close.
Jean Harrison, an attorney who has represented former condo buyers in their dealings with developers, said condo developers around the country are trying such tactics to deal with the cooling condo market.

But no local developer to date has tried to recover losses on units that it has since resold. Other developers may try to copy the move as the shakeout continues, she said.

“This is going to be a continuing problem,” Harrison said.

“This is the fruit of what happens when people are buying on speculation.”
—- —- —-

Wow. I have tried to be an advocate for the Bristol Development group located in Franklin, but I have to say that their current actions are absolutely deplorable. The risk that their buyers have taken is quantified in amount of earnest money they (the Bristol Development Group) agreed to accept. If that earnest money amount is not high enough to cover any losses created by the seller, that is the fault of the developer and not the buyer.

It would now be my personal advice to all contracted buyers who do not think that they can qualify to purchase in any Bristol Development group project to gather in one large group represented by one law firm to prepare for a class action suit. This might be the only way to fight a giant like Bristol who might be in enough financial trouble to be desperate.

To the Bristol Development Group’s Executives: I have been one of your staunchest advocates for more than 2 years and I thought that we could all pull through this economic downtown by working together. There was a great opportunity to meet in the middle and for some reason that was not good enough. But, it is my fiduciary duty to protect the buyers I represent, that is my charge as their buyer’s agent and I intend to do so to the fullest of my ability.

UPDATE 6/5/09:

It was reported in the Nashville Business Journal today that the Bristol Development Group has indeed filed lawsuits against 3 individuals for damages totaling around $80,000. When asked by the NBJ as to Bristol’s motivation for bringing these lawsuits, CEO Charles Carlisle simply replied, “People who sign a contract should expect to perform.” It is interesting to note that the Bristol Group was able to resell all of the condos that fell out of contract, some for higher prices.

I am no fool, it is clear to me that Bristol is sending this loud and clear message: If you don’t plan on closing on your contracted condo, you will get sued no matter if we resell your unit or not. I should also mention that there are at least 5 individuals who are suing the Bristol Development Group claiming “the developers fraudulently represented a shorter than expected construction time to avoid financial and other disclosures required to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.”

If you enjoyed this post, you might also like:
Bristol Development May Sue..Continued
Philosophically, Where is the Nashville Market?
WSJ Reports Slowing Mortgage Delinquencies
2 Year Analysis of Nashville Condo Prices

Speak Your Mind

*